According to Department of Veterans Affairs data and military deployment records analyzed by the Pew Research Center, combat veterans make up an estimated 1.5% to 2.5% of the total U.S. population. Those of us who make up that 2.5% population today consist mainly of veterans who partook in the conflicts of Vietnam, the Gulf War, Afghanistan and Iraq. Unlike the Greatest Generation veterans who fought under the total war of World War II, those of us who call ourselves combat veterans of these other conflicts are left with a different form of reconciliation. We find ourselves trying to reconcile the personal sacrifices we made or observed on the battlefield against changing explanations, strategic failures, and political polarization.
I still remember vividly the morning of September 11, 2001, as a fifth-grade child. My parents standing in disbelief and questioning whether to send us kids to school. Then, once arriving at school, our teachers in their own sorrow were unsure if they should proceed with class for the day. My childhood was shaped by these moments. I remember vividly driving to baseball practice with my father as we listened to President George W. Bush announcing the invasion of Iraq. To me as a child, the Middle East was the Middle East, surely Iraq and 9/11 were all the same issue.
I come from a line of veterans. My father, my grandfather and great-grandfather all served in the U.S. Air Force. I often bonded with my father over our love for American history. And as the conflicts ensued, and wartime coverage and journalism exploded, I became obsessed. Obsessed with the romanticism of the unknown. One thing I found consistent in the literature I read, “you will never know unless you have been there.” In his wartime coverage and documentaries, renowned journalist and author Sebastian Junger describes this romanticism as “the man eden.” He explains that this draw for the young man to prove himself and stand shoulder to shoulder with brothers in selfless sacrifice cannot be replicated anywhere else in society. And as a young man, growing up under the narrative that this was my generation's “war,” I understood it as my generation's calling, and I longed for my opportunity to answer that call.
Shortly after my 18th birthday I enlisted in the U.S. Army Infantry and in 2010 would leave for Basic Training and Airborne school. The following year I was assigned to the historical 1/501st Parachute Infantry Regiment and found myself on my way to the Afghanistan and Pakistan border of the Khost Province. As a 19-year-old kid, I learned very quickly the realities of war. One of these realities was that literature and film could never truly capture the overwhelming and engulfing level of controlled chaos and noise of combat. The experience of the front lines is not the same narrative being portrayed to the Americans on the other side of the globe.
Unfortunately for my senior platoon mates, this reality was already ingrained in them from their previous deployment. I was assigned to the very platoon from which, on the deployment cycle prior, Bowe Bergdahl deserted his post and was subsequently captured by the Taliban. My platoon mates were put under gag orders and could not speak to the conspiracies and lies by the media that Bergdahl, who they knew to be a deserter, was abandoned by them and left for the enemy. Their own government would later at the opportune moment of an election cycle, use this deserter in a narrative to “bring our only POW home”, at the cost of exchanging five high-ranking enemy detainees.
For my deployment, we occupied the valleys and mountains of Khost Province on the Pakistan border. Our home was combat outpost Chergowtah. Our job: be a middle finger to the Mujahideen that were trafficking weapons and fighters through the rocky valleys from the Pakistan border. Only there was a small problem, our outpost was less than 5 kilometers from the Pakistan border. A border we could not cross, but our enemies could. Our closest air support was nearly an hour away at Forward Operating Base Salerno.
Our enemy knew this, and the onslaught of unanswered rockets and mortar attacks comfortably launched from their border positions left us as sitting ducks. To add to this frustration, we were so close to the border during our missions that we could watch our attackers come and go from the Pakistan military checkpoints that were our supposed uniformed allies. This continued for the entirety of our deployment, to the very night of my departure as our helicopter ride back home was delayed due to us being rocketed and nearly struck as we sat in our small helicopter strip. Surely the platoon from the 101st Airborne Division that relieved us would continue the fight on the outpost we held and rebuilt?
In the happenstance of my reassignment to Fort Lewis, Washington, in 2014, I would run into one of the soldiers who was a part of the 30-man platoon that relieved me in 2012. He would sadly inform me that the following weeks after our departure, his platoon was given orders to pull back from the outpost. The Afghan border patrol members we served and fought with on that outpost were quickly overrun. Combat Outpost Chergowtah was now a training camp for the insurgents.
I should have known at that time that this would serve as a case study for the eventual disastrous Afghanistan withdrawal of 2021 which led to the complete establishment of a countrywide Taliban regime.
It would seem that for American soldiers after World War II, there is a clearer distinction between the people who make the decisions about war and the people who experience war firsthand. For us infantrymen, we do not determine American foreign policy. We do not establish geopolitical objectives, negotiate international agreements, or decide when the conflict should end. Our job is to receive our orders and execute them with excellence befitting our Nation. And yet, the lingering tensions, questions, and realities of our experiences remain.
The reality is that when my platoon entered the never-before-visited villages of the Hogue Valley, and inspected their bullet- and shrapnel-filled homes, the non-combatant villagers came to us in desperation, for help. We learned that the insurgents of the neighboring hilltops would use their homes as target practice for their long-range munitions and machine guns, regardless of the children standing by. This harassment and intimidation would ensure these villagers, who had yet to even see an American soldier, let alone help one, would stay in fear of the insurgents if we ever came around. When my platoon was patrolling outside of the villages of Bak, a pleading father came to my platoon leader as he read aloud the ransom note for his child who had been kidnapped by the local insurgency for ransom. On both of these occasions our interpreters made it clear, these people come to you for help because of the flag on your shoulder, they know that you care.
And he was right, for us men of 2nd platoon, Blackfoot Company, 1/501st PIR, we were there for what we believed was still true, we were there to make a difference. This is the tension at the heart of all these foreign conflicts. The fact that the larger mission cannot be defined does not change the reality of the experience on the ground for the American soldier. These human interactions are not talking points for a member of the House or Senate in their lobbying appeals, they are real. Every bullet fired, or not fired, every life lost or saved, is a moment memorialized forever in the consciousness of the American infantryman who answered his country's call.
America has become very good at thanking its veterans. We hold ceremonies, we recognize military service on national holidays, we organize parades and remind veterans that their sacrifices are appreciated. These gestures matter. But appreciation and understanding are not the same thing. There is a version of the American veteran that society is comfortable celebrating: when our outward appearance shows our resilience, our patriotism, our “red, white and blue.” But what happens when that same veteran, same experience, is left questioning the “why”?
Does our polarized society recognize that many of us veterans in this generation desperately love our country, yet despise the sickness of these open-ended wars our modern government cannot seem to be cured of. The veteran community does not become less honorable because our nation’s political decisions deserve legitimate scrutiny. Yet too often, our public discussions about veterans are focused on their sacrifices without seriously considering what those sacrifices tell us about the policies that required them.
The question our government should be lying awake considering at night is what happens when the young men of its nation no longer buy into their wars and seek the experience of “the man eden.”
America does not need to abandon its position in the world. It does not need to reject military strength or ignore genuine threats to national security. World War II was historical evidence that when America’s military is operating toward an end goal rooted in virtue, the world benefits. But military strength carries obligations. Those obligations include clearly defined objectives, honest explanations to the American public, congressional accountability and a willingness to humbly admit failure when it occurs.
Most importantly, they include an obligation to us who were asked to carry out these decisions.
We can honor those who served without defending every conflict. We can respect the fallen without pretending that every decision made in their name was correct. Perhaps the greatest injustice is not that veterans have begun questioning the wars they fought. Perhaps it is that the country has not made enough room for our questions.
A nation that asks its citizens to carry the burden of war has an obligation to listen when those citizens return home and begin to ask why?
Dedicated to SPC Malachi Villegas
07/20/1992—08/08/2016
1/501st, Blackfoot Company
2nd Platoon, 2nd squad